There were a few major topics identified when we first set out to analyze the effects of the 2018 tax bill. The link to the original post can be found (here).
One major topic was how corporations would handle the extra cash coming their way. One year out, we have some evidence as to know their behavior. A recent Bloomberg story identified analysis by Citigroup that showed corporations have spent more on stock buybacks than on capital expenditures (story here). This is the first year since 2007 that this has happened.
We mentioned in our original post how wages, stock buybacks, dividends, and capital expenditures would show the intentions of the executives of US corporations. Here is some data
- Wages grew 3.2% in 2018. That is the highest annual gain in a decade. CNBC story here.
- Stock buybacks increased to over $800 billion. That is an increase of 60% over the 2017 total of $500 billion. This happened with a stock market that ended the year 5% to the downside. (Bloomberg)
- Capital Expenditures increased $100 billion from $600 billion to $700 billion. (Bloomberg)
- Dividends increased 10% to $450 billion from $400 billion in 2017 (Bloomberg)
These numbers tell a strong story about how corporations used the extra revenue from the tax cut. It is not a healthy story. A higher than normal percentage was dedicated to buybacks. On the one hand, having that as the reason for rising earnings and stock prices is not a long term recipe for success for investors. Corporate America used the tax cut to buyback stock to boost earnings
per share that inflated bonuses while wage growth was a paltry 3%. On the other hand, it is positive news for all those execs whose bonuses are tied to earnings. It also stemmed the slide in the stock market.
Corporate America needs to take the infrastructure opportunity coming and invest those tax dollars in its employees and products.
** This blog is used for opinions and ideas and should not be used as a direction to act without doing your due diligence.**
Showing posts with label Corporate Behavior. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Corporate Behavior. Show all posts
Wednesday, March 6, 2019
Sunday, January 28, 2018
Corporate Responses to Tax Bill (AT&T, Wells Fargo)
by Michael Keane
This is part 2 of a series on the Tax Bill Likely Outcomes. A link to Part 1 is here.
When the tax bill was announced, both AT&T and Wells Fargo made announcements of employee bonuses and minimum wage level increases. Slowly but surely, other companies have made similar announcements. While this is good, it isn't a coincidence that AT&T and Wells Fargo were the first to show their support for the tax bill. There are some things missing in these announcements that cloud the meaning of the message and need to be addressed before a conclusion of corporate analysis when it comes to the tax bill.
Both AT&T and Wells Fargo currently have direct interests in the government. AT&T is going through a monster merger. Wells Fargo is currently going through legal troubles with the government. For both companies to get announcements out to show their favor of the government's new tax bill is not surprising. Both companies have also spent a lot of money (like other companies) on lobbying for the tax bill. With the way that this administration works, having these companies make these announcements right after the bill passes was not coincidence at all. It was likely a calculated decision in order to curry favor with the administration so that the government will be influenced in their decision making. The companies already had the amount of cash needed to cover the bonuses and the higher minimum wage.
Another area of compensation that has not been addressed publicly by the companies is executive bonuses. Because of the tax bill, earnings will likely be higher. Because executive bonuses can be tied to earnings and stock prices, the likelihood that executive bonuses will be at the highest level of the expected range is very strong. These bonuses will probably dwarf those actions the companies have made for the rank and file. But you won't see voluntary press releases for this. When you combine that the lower personal tax rates, you can get a decent idea as to why so much money went into lobbying for this bill.
As time progresses, take a look at executive bonuses, corporate infrastructure spending, and labor wages through earnings reports. This will tell you if the companies are reflecting their true intentions in terms of their tax bill promises. Only then can we fully understand what the true position of the companies in regards to the tax bill actually are and act accordingly.
**Disclosure - Both KDK Fund and KDK Options (partners of KeaneVCC) have had stock or options positions in AT&T and Wells Fargo in the past. There are no current holdings of either company.**
** This blog is used for opinions and ideas and should not be used as a direction to act without doing your due diligence.**
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)